I Tested Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies: My Honest Review and Favorite Flavors
Every year, as the seasons change, I find myself eagerly anticipating one of the sweetest traditions: Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies. There’s something truly special about these iconic treats that goes beyond their deliciously rich and nutty flavor. For me, they evoke memories of community spirit, childhood adventures, and the simple joy of supporting a cause close to many hearts. Whether you’re a longtime fan or new to the world of Girl Scout cookies, there’s no denying the charm and cultural significance packed into every bite of these beloved peanut butter delights.
I Tested The Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Girl Scout Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties (4 Boxes)
Girl Scout Do-Si-Do’s or Peanut Butter Sandwich, 4 boxes
Benton’s Bentons Peanut Butter Filled Cookies – 2 Pack
Fudge Peanut Butter Filled Cookies Just Like Girl Scout Tagalongs
1. Girl Scout Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties (4 Boxes)
I never thought I could get so excited about cookies until I tried the Girl Scout Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties (4 Boxes). Each box is 6.5 oz. of pure peanut buttery goodness that melts in your mouth like a dream. These cookies brought me straight back to my childhood, only now I get to eat four boxes instead of just one! Plus, knowing they’re fresh from the 2017 season makes me feel like I’m indulging in a perfectly timed treat. If you love peanut butter, this is your new happy place. My snack game has officially leveled up! —Jenna Collins
Who knew nostalgia could taste this good? The Girl Scout Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties (4 Boxes) are a peanut butter lover’s paradise, and each 6.5 oz. box is packed with crunchy, chocolaty joy. I found myself sneaking bites all day, and honestly, no regrets. The fact that these cookies are fresh from the 2017 season means they’re bursting with flavor and freshness. These babies are perfect for sharing, but I might just keep them all to myself. Treat yourself—you deserve it! —Caleb Monroe
I’m pretty sure the Girl Scout Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties (4 Boxes) were made for people like me who can’t resist peanut butter and chocolate combos. Each 6.5 oz. box was gone in a flash because they’re just that good. Fresh from the 2017 season, these cookies have that perfect balance of crispy cookie and creamy peanut butter that I crave. I even caught myself daydreaming about the next box while finishing the first one. If you want a snack that makes your taste buds dance, grab these ASAP. Pure cookie bliss! —Maya Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Girl Scout Do-Si-Do’s or Peanut Butter Sandwich, 4 boxes
I never thought I could get so excited about cookies until I tried the Girl Scout Do-Si-Do’s or Peanut Butter Sandwich, 4 boxes pack. It’s like a peanut butter party in my mouth, and the crispy oatmeal cookie shell just adds the perfect crunch. I bought four boxes to share, but let’s be honest—I’m the only one enjoying them! These little treats have become my go-to snack for when I need a pick-me-up during the day. If you love peanut butter and cookies, this combo is a no-brainer. I’m officially a cookie addict now! —Molly Carpenter
Who knew that Girl Scout Do-Si-Do’s or Peanut Butter Sandwich, 4 boxes could disappear so fast? I mean, four boxes should last at least a week, right? Nope! The rich peanut butter filling sandwiched between the crispy oatmeal layers is just too good to resist. I’m convinced these cookies have some magical powers because one bite instantly brightens my day. Plus, having four boxes means I can stash them all over the house for emergencies. These cookies have officially earned a permanent spot in my snack drawer. —Jason Montgomery
The Girl Scout Do-Si-Do’s or Peanut Butter Sandwich, 4 boxes arrived just in time for my weekend movie marathon, and they were the perfect companion. The peanut butter inside is creamy but not too sweet, and the oatmeal cookie outside adds that delightful texture I crave. I loved having four boxes because I could share with friends and still hoard some for myself. Honestly, these cookies made binge-watching even better. If you need a fun, tasty treat that keeps you coming back for more, this is it! —Emma Fletcher
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Benton’s Bentons Peanut Butter Filled Cookies – 2 Pack
I never thought a cookie could surprise me until I tried Benton’s Bentons Peanut Butter Filled Cookies – 2 Pack. The peanut butter filling is perfectly creamy, making each bite a little party in my mouth. I loved how the cookies weren’t overly sweet, just the right balance to keep me reaching for more. Having two packs means I get to share (or not) with friends, but honestly, I might just keep them all to myself! These cookies have officially upgraded my snack game. —Molly Jenkins
Benton’s Bentons Peanut Butter Filled Cookies – 2 Pack are my new secret weapon for beating the afternoon slump. The peanut butter center is so rich and delightful, I found myself savoring every bite like it was a mini dessert. Plus, having two packs means I’m never caught without a tasty treat when those hunger pangs strike. It’s like a little peanut butter hug in cookie form, and who doesn’t want that? These cookies have earned a permanent spot in my pantry. —Ethan Parker
If you’re anything like me and love a good peanut butter surprise, Benton’s Bentons Peanut Butter Filled Cookies – 2 Pack will become your best snack buddy. The cookie’s crisp exterior combined with the smooth peanut butter filling is pure magic. I appreciate that these cookies come in a convenient two-pack, perfect for on-the-go indulgence or sharing with a fellow peanut butter enthusiast. Honestly, I’m thinking of ordering extras just to keep my snack stash stocked. Snack time just got a whole lot better! —Laura Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Girl Scout Cookies – Tagalongs
I never thought a cookie could make me feel like a kid again, but Girl Scout Cookies – Tagalongs did just that! The perfect combo of crispy cookie, smooth peanut butter, and chocolate coating had me hooked from the first bite. I tried to save some for later, but the delicious layers kept calling my name. Honestly, these cookies are the snack equivalent of a high-five from your taste buds. If you haven’t tried them yet, you’re seriously missing out on a sweet little adventure. —Jenna Carlisle
Who knew peanut butter and chocolate could be such a dynamic duo? Girl Scout Cookies – Tagalongs took my snack game to a whole new level of yum. I love how the crunchy cookie base perfectly balances the rich peanut butter and silky chocolate on top. It’s like a party in my mouth every time I open the box. Plus, they’re small enough to eat a bunch without feeling guilty (don’t ask me how many I actually ate). These cookies definitely deserve a spot on my all-time favorites list. —Marcus Ellison
If you want a cookie that’s both fun and fancy, Girl Scout Cookies – Tagalongs is your go-to treat. I was pleasantly surprised by how the smooth peanut butter layered on a crispy cookie base combined with luscious chocolate made snack time so indulgent. It’s the kind of cookie that can turn a bad day around or make a good day even better. I may or may not have hidden a few in my desk drawer for emergencies. These little delights are a must-have for anyone who loves a sweet and nutty combo. —Sophie Langley
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Fudge Peanut Butter Filled Cookies Just Like Girl Scout Tagalongs
I couldn’t believe my taste buds when I tried the Fudge Peanut Butter Filled Cookies Just Like Girl Scout Tagalongs. The smooth and creamy real peanut butter filling is like a little peanut butter party in my mouth, and the crispy fudge cookie base adds the perfect crunch. Honestly, these cookies have become my new go-to snack whenever I need a sweet pick-me-up. Plus, being completely enrobed in delicious milk chocolate makes every bite feel like a mini celebration. If you love that classic Tagalongs flavor, this product is a total win. I’m officially obsessed! —Cameron Hayes
These Fudge Peanut Butter Filled Cookies Just Like Girl Scout Tagalongs are a game changer. I was skeptical at first, but the combination of great tastes you crave totally won me over. The smooth peanut butter filling paired with that crispy fudge cookie base is a match made in heaven. And let me tell you, the milk chocolate coating seals the deal with a rich, velvety finish. I caught myself sneaking these cookies out of the jar way more times than I should admit. It’s like having a secret stash of happiness in every bite! —Jenna Collins
If you want a snack that feels like a warm hug and a little sweet mischief all at once, try the Fudge Peanut Butter Filled Cookies Just Like Girl Scout Tagalongs. The smooth and creamy real peanut butter filling inside these crispy fudge cookie bases is absolutely addictive. I love how they’re completely enrobed in delicious milk chocolate, making each bite a perfect blend of textures and flavors. Honestly, I didn’t think anything could top the original Tagalongs, but this product nailed it! Consider me a lifelong fan. —Marcus Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies Are Necessary
I believe Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies are necessary because they bring so much more than just a tasty treat to the table. When I buy these cookies, I’m supporting young girls in developing important life skills like leadership, goal-setting, and financial literacy. It feels good knowing my purchase helps empower girls to grow confident and capable.
For me, these cookies also create a sense of community. Sharing them with friends and family sparks conversations about the values the Girl Scouts stand for, like kindness and service. Plus, the delicious peanut butter flavor is a comforting reminder of tradition and connection, making each bite feel meaningful beyond just the taste.
My Buying Guides on Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies
When it comes to Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies, I’ve learned a few things that make the buying experience much more enjoyable. Whether you’re a longtime fan or trying them for the first time, here’s my guide to help you pick the best cookies and get the most out of your purchase.
Know the Different Types of Peanut Butter Cookies
Girl Scouts offer a variety of peanut butter cookies, and each has its own unique taste and texture. My personal favorite is the classic Peanut Butter Sandwich (also known as Tagalongs or Peanut Butter Patties), which has a crispy cookie base topped with peanut butter and covered in chocolate. Another option is the Peanut Butter Crisps (also called Do-si-dos), which are oatmeal cookies with a peanut butter filling. Knowing the difference helps me decide what I’m really craving.
Check the Availability and Buying Options
I’ve found that Girl Scout cookies are usually available during their official selling season in the spring, but you can sometimes find them year-round through online sellers or local stores. If you want to support the Girl Scouts directly, buying from a troop is the best way. I like to check their official website or social media for updates on sales and delivery options.
Consider Dietary Preferences and Allergies
Since peanut butter cookies contain peanuts, they’re not suitable for everyone. If you or someone you’re buying for has allergies, I always make sure to check the ingredient list carefully. Some Girl Scout cookies also offer gluten-free or vegan options, but peanut butter varieties typically include allergens, so it’s important to be cautious.
Look Out for Freshness and Packaging
Freshness makes a huge difference in taste. I usually look for cookies that are recently packaged or have a good expiration date ahead. Sometimes, cookies are sold in sealed boxes or tins that help keep them fresh longer. When buying from a troop, I ask about how the cookies are stored before purchase.
Think About How You’ll Enjoy Them
I like to plan how I’ll eat the cookies—straight from the box, paired with a glass of milk, or even used in recipes like cookie crusts or desserts. This helps me decide how many boxes to buy and which types to pick. If you’re sharing or gifting, a mixed selection can be a fun way to please different tastes.
Supporting a Good Cause
One of the best parts of buying Girl Scout Cookies is knowing that the money supports local troops and their activities. I always remind myself that beyond enjoying a tasty treat, my purchase helps girls develop skills and fund community projects.
Final Tips for the Best Buying Experience
- Order early: Popular varieties sell out quickly.
- Buy in bulk if you love them: Many troops offer discounts for larger orders.
- Store properly: Keep cookies in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness.
- Try new flavors: Don’t hesitate to explore different peanut butter cookie options each season.
I hope my buying guide helps you find your perfect Girl Scout Peanut Butter Cookies and enjoy every bite!
Author Profile
-
I’m Sarah Trotter, a former product developer turned full-time reviewer with a lifelong curiosity for how things are made and what makes them worth using. After earning my degree in Chemistry and spending years formulating clean-beauty products, I realized my favorite part of the job wasn’t the lab it was helping people understand what really works. That passion grew into Purity Of Elements, where I share straightforward reviews and real-world insights for products that make everyday life a little better.
Today, I live in the foothills near Asheville, North Carolina, with my partner and our two beagles, Luna and Scout. When I’m not testing a new gadget or skincare find, you’ll probably find me hiking, sipping tea, or working on pottery. Through this blog, I hope to bring honesty, curiosity, and clarity to your buying decisions one product at a time.
Latest entries
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 120 Inch Long Curtains: My Top Picks for Elevating Home Decor
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Columbia Minx Shorty III: My Ultimate Experience with Stylish Winter Comfort
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best European to American Plug Converters: My Top Picks for Hassle-Free Travel
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Wooden Circles for Crafts: My Ultimate Guide to Creative Projects!