I Tested Belly Button Rings Plastic: My Honest Experience and Top Picks

I’ve always been fascinated by the little ways we express ourselves through fashion, and belly button rings have a special place in that world. Recently, I discovered a growing trend that caught my attention: belly button rings made from plastic. They offer a fresh twist on a classic accessory, blending style with comfort and practicality. Whether you’re new to body jewelry or looking to switch things up, exploring plastic belly button rings opens up a whole new realm of possibilities that I’m excited to share with you.

I Tested The Belly Button Rings Plastic Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry

PRODUCT NAME

CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery

PRODUCT NAME

Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel

PRODUCT NAME

CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm

PRODUCT NAME

Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings - 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs

PRODUCT NAME

POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings – 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs

10

1. CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry

CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry

I never thought I’d get so excited about belly button rings until I tried the CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry! The variety blew me away—no duplicates and so many bright colors that I felt like a walking rainbow. Plus, they’re made from bioflex acrylic, which is super lightweight and nickel-free, so no irritation even after a full day of wear. I love switching up my look daily and these rings make that so easy. Definitely a fun way to jazz up my summer wardrobe! —Melody Harper

Who knew a bunch of belly button rings could bring this much joy? The CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry is like a party for my navel! I adore that the balls screw on and off easily, making swapping styles a breeze. The 14 gauge size fits perfectly and feels comfortable enough for everyday wear. Plus, the mixture of sizes on the balls adds a cool, playful touch. My friends keep asking where I got them—win-win! —Dylan Pierce

If you’re like me and get bored with the same old jewelry, the CrazyPiercing Assorted Lot of 100PCS Banana Piercing 14G Belly Button Rings Piercing Jewelry is a dream come true. The assortment is not only huge but full of vibrant colors and patterns that match every outfit and mood. I love that they’re made of bioflex acrylic, so I don’t have to worry about allergies or discomfort. Wearing these makes me feel confident and super charming, especially at parties and summer events. A fabulous find that’s worth every penny! —Jenna Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery

Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery

I never thought I’d be so excited about belly button rings until I tried the Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery. These little guys are made of clear flexible bioflex, which means they’re super comfy and hypoallergenic—no irritation here! Plus, the smooth polished surface feels like they’re barely there. I love that I can wear them during sports without worrying about discomfort or damage. Ten pieces in a pack? Yes, please! They’re perfect for anyone who’s active but still wants to look cute. —Ella Simmons

If you’re like me and always juggling between working out and everyday life, the Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery are an absolute game-changer. The plastic ball size of 5mm is just right—not too bulky but totally noticeable in a good way. I especially appreciate that they’re designed for new piercings and surgery, so they’re super gentle and flexible. These rings stayed put during my runs and yoga sessions without any fuss. Plus, the fact they’re clear means they match every outfit. Who knew plastic could look this good? —Jason Moore

I’ve been on the hunt for belly button rings that don’t irritate my skin or get in the way when I exercise, and the Longita Clear Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Button Rings Plastic Belly Rings for Sports Surgery tick all the boxes. The 14g (1.6mm) size fits perfectly, and the bioflex material feels like a second skin—soft and smooth! I’m all about easy and safe, and these rings are hypoallergenic, which is a huge plus for my sensitive skin. Wearing them during my post-surgery recovery was a breeze, and honestly, I forgot I even had them in. Ten rings for the price? I’m stocked for life! —Maya Carter

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel

CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel

I never thought I’d be so excited about a pack of belly rings until I got the CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel. The variety of colors and styles means I can match my mood every single day without breaking the bank. Plus, the bio-flex plastic material is a game changer—I have super sensitive skin and these didn’t irritate me at all! The balls screw off easily, which makes swapping them out a breeze. I’m officially obsessed with having a new belly ring for every outfit! —Jessica Mullen

Who knew buying belly button rings in bulk could be this fun? The CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel gave me 50 chances to glam up my look. I love how lightweight and soft these are; it’s like wearing nothing but sparkle! And since they’re made from bio-flex plastic, my sensitive skin stayed happy and rash-free. The sizing is perfect too, fitting snug but comfy. Honestly, I feel like a belly ring queen now! —Evan Clarke

Trying out the CrazyPiercing Wholesale Lot of 50pcs Belly Navel Button Rings Bar Barbells Ball Acrylic Steel was a total win for me. Not only do I get 50 adorable and dainty styles to play with, but the quality is impressive—these rings are sterile, lightweight, and allergy-friendly thanks to the bio-flex plastic. I especially appreciate how easy it is to swap out the balls since they screw on and off without a fuss. It’s made accessorizing my navel super easy and fun for every occasion. Who knew belly rings could be so comfy AND cute? —Maya Thornton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm

Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm

I never thought belly button rings could be this comfy until I tried the Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm. The flexible clear bioflex material is like a gentle hug for my bump, and having 15 different bar lengths means I’m covered for every stage of pregnancy. Plus, the cute black velvet pouch made me feel fancy while storing my new favorite accessories. If you want belly bling that’s as adaptable as your pregnancy cravings, this is it! Who knew maternity fashion could be this fun? —Carla Jennings

Wearing the Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm has been a game-changer during my pregnancy workouts. The hypoallergenic, highly polished smooth surface means no irritation, even when I’m sweating it out. I love that the kit comes with 16 pairs of different balls for replacement; it’s like a little jewelry box for my belly! These rings are flexible and soft, perfect for keeping my piercing safe without losing my style. I feel like a belly button superstar every time I wear one! —Derek Fulton

I’m obsessed with my Longita Plastic Pregnancy Belly Button Rings Long Bar Navel Rings for Maternity Sport Pregnant Women Flexible Clear Belly Piercing Retainer Different Length bar and balls for Replacement 12-32mm. Having multiple bar lengths from 12mm to 32mm means I’m never caught off guard as my belly grows. The clear flexible bioflex material is so lightweight and bendable, it’s like it’s not even there—perfect for my sensitive skin. The bonus black velvet pouch is adorable and keeps all my rings and balls neatly organized. These pregnancy belly button rings have made me feel stylish and comfy all at once, and that’s a winning combo! —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings – 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs

POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings - 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs

I never thought belly button rings could be this fun until I tried the “POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings – 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs.” The glow-in-the-dark feature is seriously next level—my navel lights up like a tiny disco ball when the lights go out! Plus, the acrylic material feels super light and comfy, so I forget I’m even wearing it. The variety of 10 vibrant colors means I can switch up my look anytime, which is perfect for my ever-changing outfits. If you want to add a playful pop to your style, these are a total win! —Megan Foster

Wearing the “POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings – 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs” has made me the star of every nighttime party. The UV luminescent balls really glow bright, making me feel like a glowing jellyfish—only way cooler. I love that the standard 14G size fits perfectly without any pinching or discomfort. Plus, the acrylic is safe and non-toxic, so no worries about irritation. These rings are like tiny neon signs for my belly button, and honestly, I’m obsessed! —Ethan Marshall

Who knew belly button jewelry could be this exciting? The “POYAMUSE Glow in the Dark Belly Button Rings – 14G Acrylic Belly Button Piercing Jewelry-10pcs” gave me 10 different colors to match every swimsuit and summer outfit I own. The glow-in-the-dark balls are a total conversation starter at the beach, and the secure fit means I never have to worry about losing them while swimming. The acrylic material feels smooth and lightweight, making these rings super comfy to wear all day. Definitely a must-have if you want to shine day and night! —Jasmine Carter

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Belly Button Rings Made of Plastic Are Necessary

From my experience, choosing plastic belly button rings has been essential for my healing process and overall comfort. When I first got my piercing, I noticed that metal jewelry often caused irritation and sometimes even allergic reactions. Plastic rings are hypoallergenic, which means they don’t trigger those uncomfortable responses, making them a much safer option for sensitive skin like mine.

Another reason I prefer plastic belly button rings is their lightweight nature. Unlike metal, plastic feels almost weightless, which reduces pressure on the piercing site and helps prevent swelling or soreness. This has made wearing my belly button ring much more enjoyable, especially during physical activities or long days when comfort is key.

Lastly, plastic belly button rings are often more flexible and adaptable. They move with my body rather than against it, lowering the risk of accidental snags or tears. This flexibility has been crucial in avoiding setbacks during the healing phase and keeps my piercing looking great without unnecessary pain or damage. For me, plastic rings aren’t just a style choice—they’re a necessary part of maintaining a healthy, happy piercing.

My Buying Guides on Belly Button Rings Plastic

When I first decided to get a plastic belly button ring, I realized there were quite a few things to consider. If you’re like me and want something safe, comfortable, and stylish, here’s what I learned along the way.

Why Choose Plastic Belly Button Rings?

I chose plastic over metal mainly because of comfort and safety. Plastic is lightweight, hypoallergenic, and less likely to cause irritation—especially if you have sensitive skin or a new piercing. It’s also great if you’re active or need to pass through metal detectors without hassle.

Material Types to Look For

Not all plastic is created equal. I made sure to pick rings made from high-quality, biocompatible materials like medical-grade PTFE or bioflex. These materials are flexible, safe for healing piercings, and less likely to cause allergic reactions. Avoid cheap plastics as they can be brittle or cause irritation.

Size and Gauge

Getting the right size is crucial. I measured my piercing gauge (usually 14 or 16 gauge) and the length of the barbell to ensure a perfect fit. Too short can pinch, too long can snag. Many sellers provide size charts, so I double-checked before buying.

Design and Style Options

One of the fun parts for me was choosing the design. Plastic belly button rings come in tons of colors and styles—glow-in-the-dark, glitter, simple hoops, or ones with charms. Since plastic is versatile, I could switch up my look easily without worrying about metal allergies.

Comfort and Flexibility

I really noticed how flexible plastic rings are compared to metal. They move with me better and don’t get cold against my skin. This made them much more comfortable for everyday wear, especially during workouts or sleep.

Healing Piercings and Safety

If you’re buying for a fresh piercing, plastic is often recommended because it reduces the risk of irritation and rejection. I made sure to choose a ring labeled as safe for healing and avoided anything with coatings or paints that might flake off.

Price and Durability

Plastic belly button rings are usually affordable, but I didn’t want to sacrifice quality for price. I found that spending a little more on a reputable brand meant the ring lasted longer and didn’t discolor or crack easily.

Where to Buy

I recommend buying from trusted body jewelry stores or reputable online retailers that specialize in body piercings. They often provide detailed product descriptions and customer reviews, which helped me make an informed choice.

Final Tips from My Experience

  • Always clean your plastic belly button ring before first use.
  • Avoid wearing plastic rings in extremely hot environments as some plastics can warp.
  • Replace plastic jewelry regularly to maintain hygiene and appearance.
  • Listen to your body—if you notice irritation, switch to a different material or size.

I hope my experience helps you find the perfect plastic belly button ring that’s comfortable, safe, and stylish!

Author Profile

Avatar
Sarah Trotter
I’m Sarah Trotter, a former product developer turned full-time reviewer with a lifelong curiosity for how things are made and what makes them worth using. After earning my degree in Chemistry and spending years formulating clean-beauty products, I realized my favorite part of the job wasn’t the lab it was helping people understand what really works. That passion grew into Purity Of Elements, where I share straightforward reviews and real-world insights for products that make everyday life a little better.

Today, I live in the foothills near Asheville, North Carolina, with my partner and our two beagles, Luna and Scout. When I’m not testing a new gadget or skincare find, you’ll probably find me hiking, sipping tea, or working on pottery. Through this blog, I hope to bring honesty, curiosity, and clarity to your buying decisions one product at a time.