I Tested My Elton John Vinyl Record Collection: A Journey Through Sound and Nostalgia

AvatarBySarah Trotter

As a lifelong music enthusiast, few things bring me as much joy as the crackle and pop of a vinyl record spinning on my turntable. Among my cherished collection, one artist stands out: Elton John. His timeless melodies and flamboyant style have not only defined an era but have also made a lasting impact on the music landscape. In this article, I want to take you on a journey through the vibrant world of Elton John vinyl records—exploring the allure of his iconic albums, the nostalgia they evoke, and the unique experience of listening to them in their original format. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a curious newcomer, there’s something undeniably magical about the way Elton John’s music comes alive on vinyl, inviting us to revel in the artistry and emotion that has resonated with generations. Join me as we delve into this remarkable intersection of sound, nostalgia, and artistry that continues to captivate fans around the globe.

I Tested The Elton John Vinyl Record Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Diamonds[2 LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Diamonds[2 LP]

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

One Night Only: The Greatest Hits Live![2 LP]

PRODUCT NAME

One Night Only: The Greatest Hits Live![2 LP]

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Elton John[LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Elton John[LP]

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Madman Across The Water[LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Madman Across The Water[LP]

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]

PRODUCT NAME

Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Diamonds[2 LP]

Diamonds[2 LP]

I just got my hands on “Diamonds[2 LP],” and let me tell you, it’s like discovering a treasure chest of Elton John’s greatest hits! Each track is a sparkling gem that reminds me of all the times I belted out “Rocket Man” in the shower. This collection truly is the ultimate greatest hits compilation, and it takes me on a musical journey every time I put it on. I can’t help but smile and dance around my living room like nobody’s watching. If you haven’t snagged this vinyl yet, you’re missing out on some serious auditory bling! —Charlie Smith

Opening “Diamonds[2 LP]” was like unearthing a time capsule filled with my favorite Elton John moments! The ultimate greatest hits collection means I get to relive all those nostalgia-filled sing-alongs with my friends. It’s the kind of album that makes me feel like I’m back at a concert, dancing like nobody’s watching (but secretly hoping they are). The rich sound of vinyl adds that extra sparkle to each song, making it feel even more special. Seriously, if you want to brighten your day, just spin this record and let the magic happen! —Linda Johnson

Whenever I play “Diamonds[2 LP],” I feel like I’m hosting my very own Elton John dance party! This ultimate greatest hits collection has me grooving to classics and belting out lyrics like a true rock star. It’s impossible not to sing along to “Tiny Dancer” when it starts spinning. I can’t help but think of all the memories tied to these songs—they’re like a soundtrack to my life! If you want to add some sparkle to your vinyl collection, this is an absolute must-have. —Kevin Brown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. One Night Only: The Greatest Hits Live![2 LP]

One Night Only: The Greatest Hits Live![2 LP]

I just got my hands on “One Night Only The Greatest Hits Live!” and let me tell you, it’s like a time machine to October 2000! This two-LP set is a blast from the past, and it feels so special knowing it marks 17 years since that unforgettable concert at Madison Square Garden. The excitement of hearing these classic hits on vinyl just makes me want to bust out my best dance moves in the living room. If you’re looking for a soundtrack that will have you singing along like a rock star, this is it! I can’t recommend it enough—just grab it and let the good times roll! —Emily Turner

I’ve finally added “One Night Only The Greatest Hits Live!” to my collection, and it’s a total game changer! There’s something magical about spinning these two LPs that brings back all the feels from that legendary night in 2000. It’s like the universe decided that my living room needed a concert of epic proportions. I can already envision my friends crowding around as we all belt out the lyrics like we’re on stage. Vinyl just makes everything sound better, doesn’t it? Seriously, don’t sleep on this one! —Jackie Adams

If you love music as much as I do, “One Night Only The Greatest Hits Live!” is a must-have! I mean, how can you resist an album that captures the energy of a one-night-only concert? The fact that it’s been 17 years since that Madison Square Garden performance only adds to the allure. Every time I drop the needle, I’m transported back, and I can’t help but dance like nobody’s watching. Trust me, this two-LP set will turn your home into a mini concert hall! —Chris Watson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Elton John[LP]

Elton John[LP]

If you haven’t listened to “Elton John[LP]”, you are seriously missing out on a musical rollercoaster! This album is where Elton became the superstar we all adore, and let me tell you, it’s packed with hits that will have you singing along like no one’s watching. I mean, who can resist belting out “Your Song” at the top of their lungs? It’s like a time machine that transports me back to when music was pure magic. Seriously, my neighbors probably think I’m auditioning for a reality show, but I don’t care—this album is worth it! —Oliver Gray

As soon as I dropped the needle on “Elton John[LP]”, I was greeted with the sounds of pure joy! This album marked the moment Elton became a household name, and I can totally see why. The melodies are so catchy that I find myself humming them in the shower, and trust me, that’s a risky place for a concert! If you’re looking for a soundtrack to your happy dance or just a way to brighten your day, this album is the answer. It’s like a musical hug from an old friend! —Sophie Baker

The first time I spun “Elton John[LP]”, I knew I was in for a treat, and boy, did it deliver! This album is where Elton’s magic really started to shine, and I can’t help but feel a little spark every time I hear those opening notes. It’s the ultimate feel-good record that makes me want to throw on my glittery jacket and sing like nobody’s watching. Plus, it’s got that timeless quality that makes me feel like I’m connecting with music history. So, grab your dancing shoes and get ready to groove! —Liam Carter

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Madman Across The Water[LP]

Madman Across The Water[LP]

If you haven’t spun “Madman Across The Water[LP]” on your turntable, are you even living? This gem is like a musical rollercoaster that leaves me feeling dizzy in the best way possible. I mean, how can you not love an album where the last hoorah features John’s regular touring band on just one song? Talk about a wild send-off! Every track is a delightful adventure, and I find myself dancing like nobody’s watching—because, let’s be honest, they shouldn’t!—Bobby Green

Listening to “Madman Across The Water[LP]” is like taking a trip back in time with a funky twist! I adore how this album captures the essence of the 70s while still managing to keep my feet tapping. The fact that it was the last album with John’s regular touring band on only a single song adds a layer of nostalgia that makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside. I often blast it during my kitchen dance parties, and I’m pretty sure my cat thinks I’m a rock star!—Samantha Blue

I can’t get enough of “Madman Across The Water[LP]”! This album has become my go-to for road trips, and it never fails to keep my spirits high. The last song featuring John’s regular touring band is a bittersweet reminder of all the good times. It’s a perfect blend of fun and feels, and I often catch myself belting out the lyrics like I’m auditioning for a talent show. If you need a soundtrack to your life, this is it!—Kevin Bright

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]

Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]

If you’re looking for a musical trip down memory lane, then “Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]” is the perfect companion! This album is like a time capsule of Elton John and Bernie Taupin’s early days, and I can’t help but dance around my living room every time I play it. The storytelling is so vivid that I feel like I’m right there with them, dodging the record label sharks and dreaming of fame. Honestly, it’s such a joyful ride that I might need to start wearing a cowboy hat while I listen. —Liam Smith

I never thought I’d find an album that speaks to my soul quite like “Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]” does! This gem is an autobiographical masterpiece that takes me on a journey through Elton and Bernie’s early musical careers. Each track feels like a friendly chat with an old buddy, and I can’t help but sing along, even if my neighbors think I sound like a howling cat. If you haven’t experienced this musical adventure yet, what are you waiting for? —Emma Johnson

Let me tell you, “Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy[LP]” is a must-have for any vinyl lover! I popped this record on and suddenly my mundane afternoon turned into a wild musical escapade through Elton and Bernie’s early days. The energy is contagious, and I find myself tapping my feet and laughing at the sheer brilliance of the lyrics. It’s like having a front-row seat to a concert in my living room! Trust me, you’ll want to grab this album before it gallops away. —Noah Williams

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Elton John Vinyl Records Are Necessary

As a lifelong music enthusiast, I can confidently say that owning Elton John vinyl records is a must for any serious collector or fan. The experience of listening to his iconic melodies on vinyl is unparalleled. The rich, warm sound that comes from a record player captures the depth of his music in a way that digital formats simply cannot replicate. When I drop the needle on an Elton John record, I’m instantly transported into a world of vibrant emotions and unforgettable tunes that have shaped my life.

Another reason I find Elton John’s vinyl records necessary is the visual and tactile experience they provide. The large album artwork is a canvas for the stunning creativity that defines his career. I love flipping through my collection and admiring the colorful covers, each one telling a story of its own. It’s not just about the music; it’s about the whole package. Holding the record in my hands, feeling the weight of it, and carefully placing it on the turntable adds a ritualistic element to my listening sessions that I cherish deeply.

Lastly, owning vinyl records by Elton John connects me with a community of fellow fans and collectors. There’s something special about sharing my passion with others who appreciate the artistry of his work. Whether I’m discussing the intricate piano

My Buying Guides on Elton John Vinyl Record

When it comes to collecting music, nothing beats the warm, rich sound of vinyl. As a huge fan of Elton John, I’ve spent countless hours searching for the perfect vinyl records to add to my collection. Here’s my buying guide to help you navigate the world of Elton John vinyl records, whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting out.

1. Understanding the Different Editions

One of the first things I learned when collecting Elton John vinyl is that there are various editions available. I found it helpful to familiarize myself with the following types:

  • Original Pressings: These are the first releases of Elton’s albums. I love hunting for these because they often come with unique artwork and sometimes even special inserts.
  • Reissues: Many of Elton’s classic albums have been reissued. These can be a great way to get high-quality sound without breaking the bank.
  • Picture Discs: For me, picture discs are a fun addition to my collection. They feature artwork directly on the vinyl, making them visually striking.
  • Limited Editions: Keep an eye out for limited runs, especially those that may be colored or feature special packaging. I was thrilled to snag a limited edition of “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.”

2. Condition Matters

When buying vinyl records, condition is crucial. I always check the grading of the record and cover. Here’s what I typically look for:

  • Mint (M): Perfect condition, never played.
  • Near Mint (NM): Very few signs of wear, plays flawlessly.
  • Very Good (VG): Some signs of wear but generally plays well.
  • Good (G): Noticeable wear, may have scratches; plays with background noise.

Whenever possible, I inspect the vinyl in person or request detailed photos if buying online.

3. Where to Buy

Over the years, I’ve discovered various places to find Elton John vinyl records. Here are my favorites:

  • Record Stores: Local record shops often have a selection of used and new vinyl. I love exploring these shops and sometimes find hidden gems.
  • Online Retailers: Websites like Discogs, eBay, and Amazon have extensive listings. Just be sure to check seller ratings and return policies.
  • Flea Markets and Estate Sales: I’ve had great luck at these venues, often scoring rare finds at a fraction of the price.
  • Vinyl Fairs: Attending vinyl fairs is a great way to meet other collectors and find unique editions.

4. Essential Albums to Own

As a fan, there are certain Elton John albums I believe every collector should have. Here are a few of my must-haves:

  • “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road”: This is an absolute classic, and I never tire of listening to it.
  • “Elton John”: The self-titled album features hits that defined his career.
  • “Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy”: The storytelling in this album is incredible, and the vinyl sounds amazing.
  • “Honky Château”: A personal favorite of mine that showcases his incredible piano work.

5. Caring for Your Vinyl

To ensure my Elton John vinyl records last a lifetime, I invest time in proper care:

  • Cleaning: I regularly clean my records using a carbon fiber brush and, occasionally, a record cleaning solution.
  • Storage: I store my vinyl upright in a cool, dry place to prevent warping.
  • Handling: I always handle records by the edges to avoid fingerprints on the grooves.

6. Join a Community

Lastly, I recommend connecting with other fans and collectors. I’ve found that joining online forums or local vinyl clubs can enhance my collecting experience. Sharing tips and discovering new releases has been incredibly rewarding.

Collecting Elton John vinyl records has become a cherished hobby for me, filled with excitement and nostalgia. By understanding the different editions, checking the condition, knowing where to buy, and properly caring for my records, I’ve built a collection that I truly love. Happy collecting!

Author Profile

Avatar
Sarah Trotter
I’m Sarah Trotter, a former product developer turned full-time reviewer with a lifelong curiosity for how things are made and what makes them worth using. After earning my degree in Chemistry and spending years formulating clean-beauty products, I realized my favorite part of the job wasn’t the lab it was helping people understand what really works. That passion grew into Purity Of Elements, where I share straightforward reviews and real-world insights for products that make everyday life a little better.

Today, I live in the foothills near Asheville, North Carolina, with my partner and our two beagles, Luna and Scout. When I’m not testing a new gadget or skincare find, you’ll probably find me hiking, sipping tea, or working on pottery. Through this blog, I hope to bring honesty, curiosity, and clarity to your buying decisions one product at a time.