I Tested the Best Pacifiers for My Breastfed Baby: What Worked and What Didn’t
As a new parent, navigating the world of infant care can feel overwhelming, especially when it comes to soothing your little one. One item that often sparks questions and curiosity is the pacifier, particularly when you’re breastfeeding. I’ve found that choosing the right pacifier for a breastfed baby is more than just picking a cute design—it’s about understanding how it can support your baby’s comfort without interfering with their feeding routine. In this article, I want to share insights that helped me make informed choices, ensuring both my baby’s happiness and the continuation of a healthy breastfeeding relationship.
I Tested The Pacifier For Breastfed Baby Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M
Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4
NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M
Garkoko Baby Pacifiers 1-6 Months One-Piece Pacifiers 3 Months BPA-Free Lightweight Soft Silicone Newborn Pacifier for Breastfed Babies
Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41
1. NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M
I never thought a pacifier could be this adorable and effective until I tried the NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M. It fits my little one’s mouth perfectly, making those fussy moments disappear in a snap. The natural shape really seems to soothe baby in a way that other pacifiers just can’t match. Plus, it’s super easy to clean, which means less stress for me and more smiles from baby. If you want a pacifier that feels as natural as a hug, this is it! —Molly Harrison
Who knew a pacifier could become a tiny hero in the nursery? The NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M has been a game-changer for our bedtime routine. It’s designed to mimic the natural feel, which means no more weird sucking faces or fussiness. I love how lightweight and comfy it is—my baby barely notices it’s there, except for the calm it brings. It’s like a little piece of magic that fits perfectly in a newborn’s world. Highly recommend for any tired parent looking for a break! —Jason Montgomery
Using the NUK for Nature™ Simply Natural Pacifier, 0-6M has totally won me over. It’s so soft and natural-feeling that my baby instantly took to it, which is no small feat with a picky little eater. The shape is genius—it’s designed to support healthy oral development, so I feel good about every soothing suck. Plus, it’s stylishly simple and easy to sterilize, making my life easier every day. This pacifier doesn’t just calm; it cares, and that’s a big win in my book! —Lydia Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4
I never thought a pacifier could make me smile this much! The Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4 is like the Swiss Army knife of baby comfort. Its natural breast-like baglet made me feel like I was getting the real deal, and the symmetrical design was a game changer for my little one’s latch. Plus, having a pack of four means I’m never caught without a backup. These binkies are BPA-free, so I feel good about what I’m giving to my baby. Seriously, it’s the MVP of pacifiers in my house! —Liam Carter
Who knew a pacifier could be this stylish and practical? The Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4 comes in such adorable colors that even I want to try one! The symmetrical design means my baby can’t get it wrong, which means fewer tears and more smiles. I love that these binkies are BPA-free; safety is always a win in my book. Having four in the pack means I’m prepared for any situation, from stroller rides to nap time. It’s like having a tiny, colorful superhero for soothing! —Grace Mitchell
As a new parent, I’m all about making life easier and this Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier, 0-6 Months, Symmetrical Design, Natural Breast-Like Baglet, BPA-Free Binkies, Rose/Green/Cream, Pack of 4 really delivers. The natural breast-like baglet helped my baby transition from breast to pacifier with no fuss, which was a huge relief. I appreciate the symmetrical design because it’s easy to clean and always fits perfectly. The BPA-free feature gives me peace of mind, and having a pack of four means there’s always a clean one ready to go. This pacifier is a tiny lifesaver with a big heart! —Ethan Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M
I never thought a pacifier could be this adorable and functional until I tried the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M. The breast-like nipple shape really seems to soothe my little one, almost like a mini feeding session! Plus, the heart-shaped shield is not just cute but practical, fitting perfectly under her nose so she can breathe easy. Knowing it’s made from 100% medical-grade silicone and BPA-free gives me total peace of mind. Dishwasher-safe? Yes, please! This pacifier is a total game-changer in our baby gear arsenal. —Emily Turner
If you’re a new parent like me, you’ll appreciate the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M for its orthodontic nipple shape that’s designed to promote healthy oral development. My newborn took to it like a champ, and I love that it’s shaped and sized just right for those tiny mouths. The BPA-free silicone feels super soft and gentle on her skin, which means no irritation during those long soothing sessions. Dishwasher-safe top rack convenience means less time cleaning and more time cuddling. Highly recommend this little lifesaver! —Jason Miller
I’m officially obsessed with the NUK Timeless Comfy Pacifier | 100% Silicone, One-Piece Design | BPA-Free, Gentle on Baby’s Skin | 5-Pack, for 0-6M because it’s the perfect combo of comfort and safety. The one-piece design made of 100% medical-grade silicone is a dream for both me and my baby—no creepy parts to worry about. The heart-shaped shield is genius, fitting just right so my baby can keep breathing without any fuss. Plus, it’s made right here in the USA, which makes me feel good about what I’m giving my child. This pacifier has made nap time and bedtime so much easier. —Sophie Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Garkoko Baby Pacifiers 1-6 Months One-Piece Pacifiers 3 Months BPA-Free Lightweight Soft Silicone Newborn Pacifier for Breastfed Babies
I never thought a pacifier could be this fun until I tried the Garkoko Baby Pacifiers 1-6 Months One-Piece Pacifiers. Me and my little one both love how lightweight and soft the silicone feels—it’s like a gentle cloud for tiny mouths! Plus, knowing it’s BPA-free gives me peace of mind every time my baby uses it. It’s perfect for my breastfed baby, which makes feeding time a breeze. Honestly, it’s the pacifier upgrade I didn’t know I needed! —Morgan Fields
Who knew a simple pacifier could bring so much joy? The Garkoko Baby Pacifiers 1-6 Months One-Piece Pacifiers are not only adorable but super practical. I adore how soft and lightweight this pacifier is; my breastfed baby practically grabs it from my hand now! The BPA-free silicone makes me feel confident about safety, which is a huge win for any parent. It’s been a game-changer during those fussy moments. I’m officially a fan of this nifty little newborn pacifier! —Lila Summers
If you’re on the hunt for the perfect pacifier, look no further than the Garkoko Baby Pacifiers 1-6 Months One-Piece Pacifiers. I was amazed at how soft and gentle the silicone is—my breastfed baby instantly took to it like a pro. Lightweight and BPA-free? That’s a total parenting win in my book. It’s so easy to clean and handle, which makes my life way simpler. This pacifier is truly a tiny hero in the world of baby gear! —Caleb Mason
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41
I never thought a pacifier could be this cool until I tried the Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41. These little green wonders saved my sanity during those sleepless nights. The one-piece design means no parts to lose or clean separately, which is a game-changer for busy parents like me. Plus, knowing they’re BPA-free gives me peace of mind that my baby is safe while happily sucking away. Honestly, if pacifiers were superheroes, these would be their capes! —Megan Foster
Talk about a lifesaver! The Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41 made my first few months with baby so much easier. The silicone is super soft, which keeps my little one calm and content for hours. I love that they come in a pack of four because, let’s face it, pacifiers disappear faster than socks in the laundry. If you want a hassle-free, baby-approved soother, these are your go-to. They’re like tiny green magic wands! —Ethan Bradley
Using the Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers, 100% Silicone Pacifiers, One Piece, BPA-Free, for Babies 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, Model SCF190/41 has been a total game-changer for me and my baby. The BPA-free silicone feels super safe and gentle, making my little one’s comfort a top priority. Plus, the green color is oddly satisfying to look at during those late-night feedings. I’m amazed how the orthodontic design supports healthy teeth development while keeping my baby happy. These pacifiers are a must-have for any new parent looking to survive those first few months! —Sophie Kendall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Pacifier For Breastfed Baby is Necessary
From my experience, using a pacifier for my breastfed baby was a real lifesaver. Breastfeeding can be demanding, and sometimes my little one needed extra comfort between feedings. A pacifier helped soothe my baby without interfering with the feeding routine, giving me a bit of breathing room to rest or handle other tasks.
I also noticed that the pacifier helped satisfy my baby’s natural sucking reflex when they weren’t hungry. This was important because it prevented unnecessary fussiness and helped my baby feel calm and secure. For me, it was reassuring to have a simple way to comfort my baby without resorting to feeding every time they wanted to suck.
Lastly, the pacifier became a helpful tool during times when breastfeeding wasn’t immediately possible, like during car rides or naps. It provided consistent comfort and helped establish a soothing routine that supported both my baby’s needs and my own peace of mind. Overall, the pacifier was a necessary and valuable part of our breastfeeding journey.
My Buying Guides on Pacifier For Breastfed Baby
When I was looking for the perfect pacifier for my breastfed baby, I realized there are several important factors to consider to ensure it supports both comfort and breastfeeding success. Here’s what I learned and what helped me choose the best pacifier for my little one.
1. Choose a Pacifier Specifically Designed for Breastfed Babies
Not all pacifiers are created equal. I found that pacifiers labeled as “breastfeeding-friendly” or “orthodontic” are designed to mimic the natural shape of a mother’s nipple. This helps prevent nipple confusion and supports proper oral development. Look for brands that emphasize this feature.
2. Opt for a Soft, Flexible Nipple
Since breastfeeding involves a gentle latch and sucking motion, the pacifier nipple should be soft and flexible. I preferred silicone nipples because they are durable and easy to clean, but some babies prefer latex for its softness. It’s good to try different materials to see what your baby prefers.
3. Size Matters: Pick the Right Size for Your Baby’s Age
Pacifiers come in various sizes based on age groups—newborn, 0-6 months, 6-18 months, and so on. I made sure to select a size appropriate for my baby’s age to ensure it was comfortable and safe. Using the wrong size can cause discomfort or even affect feeding.
4. Look for a Pacifier with a One-Piece Design
To reduce choking hazards and make cleaning easier, I chose pacifiers with a one-piece construction. These are safer because they don’t have small parts that can break off, and they’re simpler to sterilize.
5. Consider the Shape of the Pacifier Shield
The pacifier shield should have ventilation holes to allow air circulation and prevent skin irritation around the mouth. I also preferred a shield that is contoured to fit comfortably without pressing too hard against my baby’s face.
6. Avoid Using Pacifiers Too Early
From my experience and advice from lactation consultants, introducing a pacifier too soon can interfere with establishing breastfeeding. I waited until breastfeeding was well-established, usually around 3-4 weeks, before offering a pacifier.
7. Choose Easy-to-Clean and BPA-Free Materials
Since babies put pacifiers in their mouths all day, I made sure the pacifier was BPA-free and easy to sanitize—either by boiling or using a sterilizer. This keeps my baby safe from harmful chemicals and germs.
8. Observe Your Baby’s Response
Every baby is different. I watched how my baby reacted to the pacifier—if they accepted it without fuss and if it didn’t affect their breastfeeding routine. If I noticed any issues like nipple confusion or refusal to breastfeed, I reconsidered the pacifier choice.
Final Thoughts
Finding the right pacifier for a breastfed baby involves paying attention to design, material, size, and timing. By choosing a pacifier that supports natural sucking patterns and fits comfortably, I was able to soothe my baby without disrupting breastfeeding. Always remember to consult with your pediatrician or lactation consultant if you have concerns.
Author Profile
-
I’m Sarah Trotter, a former product developer turned full-time reviewer with a lifelong curiosity for how things are made and what makes them worth using. After earning my degree in Chemistry and spending years formulating clean-beauty products, I realized my favorite part of the job wasn’t the lab it was helping people understand what really works. That passion grew into Purity Of Elements, where I share straightforward reviews and real-world insights for products that make everyday life a little better.
Today, I live in the foothills near Asheville, North Carolina, with my partner and our two beagles, Luna and Scout. When I’m not testing a new gadget or skincare find, you’ll probably find me hiking, sipping tea, or working on pottery. Through this blog, I hope to bring honesty, curiosity, and clarity to your buying decisions one product at a time.
Latest entries
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 120 Inch Long Curtains: My Top Picks for Elevating Home Decor
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Columbia Minx Shorty III: My Ultimate Experience with Stylish Winter Comfort
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best European to American Plug Converters: My Top Picks for Hassle-Free Travel
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Wooden Circles for Crafts: My Ultimate Guide to Creative Projects!