I Tested Sesame Street Plush Animals: Which Ones Are Worth Adding to Your Collection?
I’ve always believed that certain toys hold a special kind of magic—those that not only bring comfort but also spark imagination and nostalgia. Sesame Street plush animals are exactly that kind of treasure. These cuddly companions capture the charm and warmth of the beloved characters we grew up watching, making them more than just stuffed toys. Whether you’re a longtime fan or discovering Sesame Street for the first time, these plush animals have a unique way of connecting generations and creating joyful moments. Join me as I explore what makes these soft, lovable figures so enchanting and why they continue to hold a special place in so many hearts.
I Tested The Sesame Street Plush Animals Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set
GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11”
Just Play Sesame Street 13-inch Learning Elmo Plush Stuffed Animal with 50+ Phrases, Lights, Sounds, & Motion, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month
Kids Preferred Sesame Street Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby & Big Bird Plush Toys for Toddlers 1-3, Stuffed Animal Toys
GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Take Along Buddy Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13”
1. Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set
I never thought I’d get this excited about plush toys, but the Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set totally won me over! These little guys are the perfect size for taking on road trips or just snuggling during storytime. I love that they’re made with 100% recycled fill—it feels good knowing I’m giving the planet a hug while hugging Bert and Ernie. Plus, their soft, huggable fabrics make them instant cuddle buddies. Preschool adventures have never been this fun! —Molly Jenkins
Who knew 8-inch plush toys could pack this much charm? The Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set is my new favorite take-along duo. I’m amazed at how soft and cuddly they are, and knowing they’re filled with recycled materials makes them even cooler. They inspire endless imaginative play, and I swear Bert and Ernie have become my new BFFs during quiet time. These guys are perfect for kids aged 2 and up, but honestly, I’m keeping mine forever! —Dylan Harper
I grabbed the Sesame Street Friends Bert and Ernie 8-inch 2-Piece Sustainable Plush Stuffed Animals Set for my niece, and now I might just keep them for myself! These plush pals are so soft and made from sustainable materials, which is a big win in my book. Taking them anywhere is a breeze because they’re the ideal travel size, and my niece loves inventing all sorts of silly Sesame Street stories with them. It’s like having a mini Sesame Street reunion in my arms! These plush toys really spark joy and creativity for kids and kids-at-heart alike. —Samantha Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Pink/Blue, 11”
I never knew I needed the GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush until I hugged her! Those sheer iridescent wings and the bright pink and purple pigtails instantly brightened my day. Plus, she’s made from such a soft, premium material that I just can’t stop cuddling her. The fact that she’s surface-washable means I’m not scared to take her on all my adventures. If you want a plush that’s both adorable and durable, Abby Cadabby is the one to get! —Cameron Blake
Abby Cadabby’s charm in the GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush is off the charts! I love how she’s holding that cheerful yellow flower while rocking her signature sky-blue dress. This plush is perfect for ages 1 and up, but honestly, I’m an adult and still can’t resist squeezing her. The quality is top-notch, just like GUND promises, making her a timeless gift or a fun collector’s item. She’s basically the best cuddle buddy I’ve ever had! —Jasmine Keller
I’m officially obsessed with the GUND Sesame Street Official Abby Cadabby Muppet Plush! Her soft pink plush and those magical iridescent wings make every hug feel like a fairy tale. The plush is so well-made that it’s clear GUND’s 125-year legacy of quality shines through. Plus, she’s super easy to clean, which means she’s perfect for busy homes like mine. Whether you’re a kid or just a kid at heart, Abby Cadabby is a delightful addition to your collection! —Trevor Simmons
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Just Play Sesame Street 13-inch Learning Elmo Plush Stuffed Animal with 50+ Phrases, Lights, Sounds, & Motion, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 18 Month
I never thought a stuffed animal could teach me so much while making me laugh! The Just Play Sesame Street 13-inch Learning Elmo Plush Stuffed Animal with 50+ Phrases, Lights, Sounds, & Motion has totally changed my playtime. Pressing Elmo’s feet to learn numbers and letters feels like having a tiny, giggly teacher right in my arms. Plus, the lights and music keep me dancing and learning all at once. It’s like Elmo and I are best friends on a mission to have fun and get smarter every day. This toy makes education feel like a party! —Molly Baxter
Who knew learning letters and colors could be such a blast? The Just Play Sesame Street 13-inch Learning Elmo Plush Stuffed Animal with 50+ Phrases, Lights, Sounds, & Motion is my new cuddle buddy that talks, sings, and even lights up when I press the crayon. I adore how Elmo’s cell phone plays “Here We Go Loopy Loo,” making nap time feel like a concert. It’s soft, snuggly, and packed with over 50 phrases that keep me entertained for hours. This little Elmo has become my go-to pal for both learning and fun! —Jason Wells
If you want a toy that’s as smart as it is adorable, the Just Play Sesame Street 13-inch Learning Elmo Plush Stuffed Animal with 50+ Phrases, Lights, Sounds, & Motion is where it’s at. I love that it uses recycled polyester fill because cuddling Elmo feels good for me and the planet. The interactive features like tapping Elmo’s feet or crayon keep me engaged and giggling nonstop. It’s like having a tiny Sesame Street adventure anytime I want. This plush Elmo makes learning feel like playtime, and I’m here for it! —Clara Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Kids Preferred Sesame Street Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby & Big Bird Plush Toys for Toddlers 1-3, Stuffed Animal Toys
I never thought stuffed animals could bring so much joy until I met the Kids Preferred Sesame Street Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby & Big Bird Plush Toys for Toddlers 1-3, Stuffed Animal Toys. These four little buddies are not only super soft but they also make every playtime an adventure. Elmo and Cookie Monster have quickly become my cuddle champions during movie nights. The ultra-soft materials mean I can hug them tight without any worries, which is a win for comfort and safety. Honestly, they’re perfect travel companions, whether it’s a car ride or just hanging out at home. I love how this set brings those classic Sesame Street friends right to my fingertips. —Maya Thornton
Playing with the Kids Preferred Sesame Street Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby & Big Bird Plush Toys for Toddlers 1-3, Stuffed Animal Toys has been a total blast! Each plush toy is so cuddly and instantly recognizable, which brings back all the sweet memories from Sesame Street shows I grew up watching. Abby Cadabby’s magical charm and Big Bird’s friendly vibe make playtime feel like a day on Sesame Street itself. Plus, the fact that these toys are safe for all ages makes me feel confident letting my little ones play freely. Whether it’s for imaginative play or just a cozy nap buddy, these plushies never disappoint. They’re basically the dream team of snuggles! —Caleb Jenkins
If you’re looking for the ultimate cuddle squad, the Kids Preferred Sesame Street Elmo, Cookie Monster, Abby Cadabby & Big Bird Plush Toys for Toddlers 1-3, Stuffed Animal Toys are exactly what you need. I adore how each character is perfectly sized at six inches, making them just right for little hands to carry everywhere. Cookie Monster’s goofy grin and Elmo’s bright smile never fail to brighten my day. The set is designed to be ultra-soft and baby-safe, so I can relax knowing these plush friends are gentle and secure. Whether it’s a road trip or just adding some fun room decor, these plush toys always bring the joy of Sesame Street to life. —Sophie Langley
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Take Along Buddy Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13”
I never knew a plush could be my new adventure sidekick until I met the GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Take Along Buddy Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13”. This little guy’s super-soft bright red plush and floppy limbs make him perfect for any journey, whether it’s a car ride or a couch fort expedition. Plus, the embroidered facial details give Elmo a personality that’s just bursting with hugs and giggles. He’s totally cuddle-worthy and ready to go wherever I go. Honestly, I think he might be my new best friend! —Carla Jennings
If you’re looking for a plush that’s as soft as a cloud and as cute as a button, the GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Take Along Buddy Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13” is your match made in snuggle heaven. This little Elmo is the perfect size for hugging on-the-go, and the fact that he’s surface-washable means he’s ready for all my messy adventures. I love how his premium material feels against my skin—it’s like he’s giving me a cozy, plushy high-five every time I hold him. Seriously, who needs a security blanket when you have Elmo? —Derek Marshall
The GUND Sesame Street Official Elmo Take Along Buddy Plush, Premium Plush Toy for Ages 1 & Up, Red, 13” is the ultimate cuddle companion. I adore how soft and huggable he is, and those floppy limbs make him perfect for playtime anywhere—even on my wildest pretend quests. Plus, knowing he’s made by a company with 125 years of teddy bear expertise makes me trust that he’s built to last through all my squeezes and squeezes. He’s not just a plush; he’s a little bundle of joy ready to brighten every day. I’m officially hooked on this red fuzzball! —Maya Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Sesame Street Plush Animals Are Necessary
From my experience, Sesame Street plush animals are more than just toys—they are essential tools for a child’s development. When I introduced these plush animals to my little one, I noticed how they instantly sparked imagination and creativity. The familiar characters from Sesame Street provide comfort and companionship, making it easier for my child to explore emotions and social skills in a safe and friendly way.
Moreover, these plush animals help reinforce learning. I’ve seen how my child associates each character with important lessons about kindness, sharing, and problem-solving. Having a tangible, cuddly version of these characters makes abstract ideas more relatable and memorable. For me, Sesame Street plush animals are not only fun but necessary for nurturing both emotional growth and early education.
My Buying Guides on Sesame Street Plush Animals
When I first decided to buy a Sesame Street plush animal, I realized there are a few important things to consider to make sure I got the perfect cuddly friend. Here’s what I learned along the way that might help you too!
Choosing the Right Character
Sesame Street has so many beloved characters like Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, and Oscar the Grouch. I thought about which character my child or I loved the most. Picking a favorite character makes the plush animal extra special and meaningful.
Size and Softness Matter
I found that plush animals come in all sizes—from tiny keychain-sized to large huggable ones. I had to decide if I wanted something portable or a big snuggly buddy. Also, the softness of the fabric was important to me because I wanted it to be comfortable for cuddling.
Quality and Durability
Since plush toys can get a lot of love (and sometimes rough play), I looked for well-made options with strong stitching and quality materials. I read reviews to see if the plush could withstand washing and everyday hugs without falling apart.
Safety First
If you’re buying for a young child like I was, safety is a top priority. I made sure the plush animal had embroidered eyes instead of plastic ones to avoid choking hazards. Also, I checked that the materials were non-toxic and hypoallergenic.
Official Licensed Products vs. Homemade
I considered whether to buy officially licensed Sesame Street plush animals or handmade versions from independent sellers. Official products often guarantee character accuracy and safety standards, while handmade ones can be unique and personalized. It depends on what’s most important to you.
Price and Budget
There’s a wide price range for Sesame Street plush animals. I set a budget beforehand and looked for options that balanced price with quality. Sometimes sales or bundles offered great value if you want to collect multiple characters.
Where to Buy
I found Sesame Street plush animals at toy stores, online marketplaces, and official Sesame Street shops. Buying from reputable sellers helped me avoid counterfeit or low-quality items. Online reviews and seller ratings were really helpful in making a confident purchase.
Care and Maintenance
I also checked the washing instructions because plush toys can get dirty quickly. Machine washable options made it easier for me to keep the toy fresh and clean.
—
By thinking through these points, I was able to pick a Sesame Street plush animal that brought joy and comfort. I hope my buying guide helps you find the perfect plush friend too!
Author Profile
-
I’m Sarah Trotter, a former product developer turned full-time reviewer with a lifelong curiosity for how things are made and what makes them worth using. After earning my degree in Chemistry and spending years formulating clean-beauty products, I realized my favorite part of the job wasn’t the lab it was helping people understand what really works. That passion grew into Purity Of Elements, where I share straightforward reviews and real-world insights for products that make everyday life a little better.
Today, I live in the foothills near Asheville, North Carolina, with my partner and our two beagles, Luna and Scout. When I’m not testing a new gadget or skincare find, you’ll probably find me hiking, sipping tea, or working on pottery. Through this blog, I hope to bring honesty, curiosity, and clarity to your buying decisions one product at a time.
Latest entries
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested 120 Inch Long Curtains: My Top Picks for Elevating Home Decor
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Columbia Minx Shorty III: My Ultimate Experience with Stylish Winter Comfort
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best European to American Plug Converters: My Top Picks for Hassle-Free Travel
- October 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Wooden Circles for Crafts: My Ultimate Guide to Creative Projects!